To write a metaphor in a lyric, give a feeling or relationship the properties of something concrete. Choose one thing that object can do, and let it happen in the verse. Cover the line that explains the comparison. Read the remaining lines and write down what they let you infer. Keep a plain line if it tells the listener something the image alone cannot supply.
Find the verb hiding inside the object
Start with a private sentence you would happily leave out of the song. Ours is “My brother and I can be civil through Sunday lunch.” A vase, a chair and a tablecloth could all appear in that kitchen. Which one does the thing the truce does? A folding chair can be set out for company and put away when company goes. Those two movements give the writer a beginning and an ending.
The Academy of American Poets describes metaphor as comparing unlike things or giving one thing a description that literally belongs to another. “Our truce is a folding chair” makes that connection outright. You can name the truce in the opening line and still leave room for the listener to discover what kind of truce these people have.
Cover the line that gives the answer away
Read the earlier verse in the example below. Cover “We only get along at lunch” and read lines one, two and four together. The narrator sets out the chair for the other person and folds it at the first sign of departure. The visit gives their peace a time limit. We can infer that much even with a finger over line three.
Now ask what you actually lose. A chair and a plate suggest a meal, but they cannot tell us which meal it is. Nor do they establish that these two people are brothers. If the next verse needs either fact, put it somewhere the listener can hear it. Your private sentence gives you a way to check what a draft conveys. The listener never sees that sentence.
At the writing desk
A Sunday truce in four lines
First thought
Our truce is a folding chair
I set it out beside your plate
We only get along at lunch
I fold it when you take your coat
Another way in
Our truce is a folding chair
I set it out beside your plate
One short leg ticks on the tile
I fold it when you take your coat
- Lines one, two and four stay fixed. Setting the chair out and folding it again give the truce a duration.
- The new third line lets the strain make a small sound. It also gives up the earlier line’s explicit claim about lunch.
- Neither verse identifies the guest as a brother. If that relationship matters to the ending, try the plain-spoken alternative in the lesson.
Original practice lyrics. Try the explanatory line, the ticking leg and a line of direct address over the same phrase.
Give the vacant line a job
Try “One short leg ticks on the tile.” A chair that rocks under a guest can make that small repeated noise. The verse gains a sound to sing and a reason the peace might feel precarious underneath the polite gesture. The line leaves open whether the guest is restless or simply trying to sit still. That uncertainty suits this particular lunch.
You can also sing straight from the plate to the coat, leaving space where line three used to be. That version puts the weight on how quickly the visit seems to end. Or try a piece of plain speech in the gap, such as “You’re still my brother, Len.” Now the listener knows who came to lunch, and hears someone risk saying it. Choose according to what you want the fourth line to mean after that.
Check what the next verb asks you to picture
Try an intentionally awkward third line aloud, “By pudding our truce runs aground.” For a moment there is a boat in the kitchen. If you wanted the listener to stay with the chair until it folds, it takes work to get them back from the water. Circle the verb that moved the scene. Try a sound, weight or motion the chair can actually produce in its place.
A change of image can earn its space. A later verse set on the ferry home might give that boat somewhere to appear. For this four-line trial, keep the kitchen still and change one line at a time. Speak each version into the same pause before “I fold it”. Notice whether you anticipate the closing chair or spend the pause trying to locate the boat.
Save the version that leaves the right question open
Pick a comparison from your own draft. In the scratchpad, name the thing being compared, its physical counterpart and two actions the counterpart allows. Write one line explaining what it all means. Cover it. Write down one inference the surviving words support and one fact you only know because you wrote them. Those two notes tell you where to spend a line.
If you need a fresh object, open the Songwriting Prompt Generator and choose Imagery. “Try another prompt” moves through the exercises. Use a detail from one prompt, then return to your own comparison. Download your scratchpad before leaving if you want to keep the versions. Read your chosen lines over the same melody or pulse and listen for the moment the meaning arrives.
Test what your metaphor can carry
Take two minutes to choose a comparison and list two actions its object permits. Spend three minutes writing a short verse with one line that explains it. Cover that line and spend three minutes trying silence, a physical detail and one new fact in the gap. Use the final two minutes to read the versions aloud, pick one, and save the verse with a note about what a listener can infer.
- Which words give my listener a reason for the inference I want?
- Can the object do the action I wrote, or have I introduced another picture?
- Does the plain line carry information, voice or rhythm I want to keep?
A scratchpad, not a saved project. Copy or download your work before leaving.
You choose when to load this into your draft. No AI generation starts automatically.
A few useful answers.
Should I cut every line that explains a lyrical metaphor?
Keep a line that changes what we know or lets the speaker do something. “You’re still my brother, Len” names a relationship and addresses the guest. Try cutting a line when it only repeats an inference the surrounding verse already earns.
How long should I extend one metaphor in a song?
Try two actions and stop when the next one costs more than it adds. Setting out the chair and folding it give this example a complete arc. More details about hinges or upholstery would need a new purpose in the scene.
How do I tell whether my comparison is too obscure?
Read the verse to someone without the private explanation and ask what changed between the people. If they picture the chair but miss the relationship you care about, try one point of contact, such as who brought the chair or who is sitting in it.